Why all the buzz about long tail keyword research?

Posted on March 19, 2007
Filed Under | Leave a Comment

I am terribly opinionated about the waste of time I find ‘long tail’ keyword research to be.  That’s because I look at search with a SEO (Search Engine Optimization) view not a PPC (Pay Per Click) view.  Totally different things, these two.

Pay Per Click is to Shotguns as SEO is to _____________________

What do you think the answer is?

Before you volunteer, let’s talk about pay per click and why I see it relating to shotguns.  In PPC, you pay for every visitor to your site.  Now even if you are Amazon and convert at a whopping 7%, you are still not selling 93 out of every 100 visitors.  So paying for 93 misses hurts. And if you are converting at less than 1% like most websites do, you are missing 99 out of 100 folks.  So the idea is to shoot shot at a big group of folks (a long keyword list with many different keyword phrases to target each of the individuals) and see where your shot is effective.  Then you reload as quickly as you can, perhaps modestly change your direction, and shoot again.  Conceptually as you go along, your shot becomes more effective at producing sales.  Make sense?

The biggest difference between PPC and SEO is time and specific feedback.  With PPC set up is fast (you can be live with a PPC campaign in a few minutes once you’ve done your keyword research) and you know immediately if you are hitting the target or not assuming you log into your account once a day or more.  Better yet you know which of your ’shot’ (keywords) hit the target.  So it makes sense to shoot as much shot as you can (lots of folks with different terms – not a lot of folks with one term), watch the results and then regroup and reshoot incorporating the feedback information.  Now loads of folks lose money on PPC even with all this feedback which is mostly a matter of the money loser either not accepting the feedback or ignoring the cost/profit relationship of their product market.

In SEO there is a bunch of work that starts after you complete your keyword research and then you wait and then you see if you moved forward or back and then you work again.  The time lag can be days or even weeks depending on how often a page is crawled by search engine spiders.  And if you change mulitple items at once, you have to then analyze what was the likely factor the moved you forward or backward.  Those who would recommend that anyone focus on long tail keywords for SEO is probably making the assumption that the work involved in ranking for a phrase that may get 1,000 visitors a day versus one that may get only 10 visitors a day is proportional.  Thus, they reason you should work on 100 pages for those 10 visitors each rather than work on one page for 1000.  That way if only half of them get to a top position, you are still likely to make money than to work endlessly on a competitive phrase that, they will tell you, you may not win.

The work involved with SEO ranking is not proportional.  That’s the fallacy underlying the SEO long tail theory.  Ranking for a 10 visitor a day search term is not 1% the effort that ranking for a 1000 visitor a day search term.  It’s not as much effort and it’s not as much time but it’s a lot more than 1% of the effort.

Now layer in the error rate in long tail.  What is forecasted for long tail terms can be notoriously off and you never know which terms are close to the prediction and which ones are way off.  A recent example I just learned was on a baseball site owned by a coaching client of mine.  Without any intent, we ended up ranking for ‘cheap softball gloves’, ‘cheap baseball gloves’, cheap softball bats’, and cheap baseball bats’.  These terms were pulling in a few visitors every day.  Well then I wondered how the ‘cheap’ phrases would stack up against the same phrases using the modifier ‘discount’.  I went out and checked two different keyword tools.  Here just one example:

Cheap Softball Bats                       Discount Softball Bats
Wordtracker                      22                                                 95
Trellian                            1,295                                             1085

Now just look at these numbers from a relative view because you can’t compare the gross numbers between the tools.  WordTracker says that discount softball bats is likely to be almost 5x more traffic than cheap softball bats.  Trellian says that the modifier ‘cheap’ is actually a bit more popular than ‘discount’.  So the first issue we have is who is more likely to be right on this particular query.  I highlighted that last part because I think that the one most likely to be right will change from query to query and I’ll never know which one is more accurate unless I actually successfully rank on any terms I’m comparing and check.  My guess was that Wordtracker was more accurate here.  Not sure why I thought that now.

Cheap Softball Bats                     Discount Softball Bats
Google Position                        7                                          8
MSN Position                           4                                           n/m
Yahoo Position                        n/m                                        n/m

n/m = not meaningful (any long tail position that is not on page one of a search engine is really not a meaningful position – it won’t bring any traffic)

Now here are the actual traffic results over the last 4 days:

    Cheap Softball Bats                    Discount Softball Bats
Google Traffic                        9                                                   2
MSN Traffic                           4                                                   0
Yahoo Traffic                         0                                                   0

Isn’t that interesting?  ‘Cheap’ way outperforms ‘discount’ even when we just focus on Google traffic where the positions are nearly identical.  And I didn’t put a lick of effort into getting the ‘cheap’ phrases they just came to us.  I did put work into trying to rank on ‘discount’.  I wasted my time.

Now there is one more dimension you really need to know about how SEO really works and then you’ll understand why I only spend real time on big phrases.  When a search engine finds you highly relevant on a big traffic, shorter term you will naturally get ranked on all sorts of variants were a second or third word is tacked on if all you do is place these words in your Meta tags, once or twice on your visible text and a sprinkling of times in links.  That’s really all you need to do.  Here’s an example of that.  Type in ‘golf gift’ and TGC is #1  type in ‘golf gift ideas’ and depending on the search engine, we are #1 – #3.  Now we make it really long tail and type in ‘golf gift ideas for tournaments’ and we are still between #1 and #3.  Am I trying to get ‘golf gift ideas for tournaments’?  No.  Do we have it anyway?  Yes.  That’s why long tail ranking is NOT proportional effort.  SEO doesn’t work that way.

You are better off aiming a big gun at a big target with SEO.

Pay Per Click is to Shotgun as SEO is to Cannon.

Comments

Leave a Comment

If you would like to make a comment, please fill out the form below.

Name (required)

Email (required)

Website

Comments

Get Your SEO News First!


Pages


Recently


Categories


Archives

  • Buy Cheapest canada prescription drugs Online Best Prices. 24/Online Pharmacy.
  • Buy Cheapest buy ativan from europe Online Best Online. Cheap Online Pharmacy.
  • Buy Cheap phentermine websites Online Low Prices. Discount Online Pharmacy.
  • Buy Cheap newest drug for depression Now Buy Medications Online. Guaranteed Shipping.
  • Buy Cheap pharmacy norvasc Now 24/Internet)(safe Pharmacy. Best Prices.
  • Buy Cheap prescription drugs for obesity Now Guaranteed Shipping. Free Viagra Pills!
  • Buy valium low cost Online Without Prescription. Best Online. Low Prices.
  • Buy Cheap prescription drug canada Now Drugs, Health And Beauty. Guaranteed Shipping.
  • Buy Cheapest norco pain meds for sale Online Cheap Online Pharmacy. Best Internet.
  • Buy Cheap walgreen pharmacy Now Buy Medications Online. WorldWide Shipping.
  • Buying Cheapest cheap cheap viagra. Mexican Pharmacy, Good Prices. Best Online.
  • Buy Cheapest buy ultram where Now Special Prices For buy ultram where! Pharmacy Store.
  • Buy Cheap diet pill online Online Best Online. Special Prices For diet pill online!
  • Buy Cheap bayer levitra cheapest price online pharmacy Now Low Prices. No Prescription Online Pharmacy.
  • Buy Cheapest valtrex coupon Now 24/Online Pharmacy. Pharmacy Store.
  • Buy Cheap trazodone used for Now Best Online. Cheap Meds Without Prescription.
  • Buy Cheap buy cialis tadalafil Online Pharmacy Store. Online Medical Shop.
  • Buy Cheap herbal drugstore Online Best Prices. Order Cheap Meds Without Rx.
  • Buy Cheapest paypal ultram Now The Largest Internet Pharmacy. Low Prices.
  • Buy Cheap mexican prescription drugs Now Drugs, Health And Beauty. Best Drugstore.
  • Buy Cheap tips to curb your appetite Online Drugs, Health And Beauty. Low Prices.
  • Buy Cheap female viagra uk Now Top Online Pharmacy. No Prescription Needed.
  • Buy Cheapest side effects of levitra Online No Prescription Needed. Best Internet.
  • Buy Cheapest cheap no prescription viagra Online Cheap Online Pharmacy. Pharmacy Store.
  • Buy Cheap new medicines for depression Online Free Viagra Pills! Buy Medications Online.
  • Buy Cheapest atenolol tablets Online Online Prices For atenolol tablets! Best Internet.
  • Buy neck pain products Without Prescription Doctor. Best Prices. Best Internet.
  • strong over the counter diet pills Online Without Prescription WorldWide Shipping. Best Prices.
  • Buy Cheap cost of accutane Now Best Drugstore. No Prescription Needed.
  • Buy Cheapest cialis fda Online WorldWide Shipping. Online Medical Shop.
  • Buy Cheapest phentermine sales Now Cheap Online Pharmacy. Guaranteed Shipping.
  • Buy Cheapest valium without a perscription Online Best Internet. Top Online Pharmacy.
  • Buy Cheap ultram addiction Now The Largest Internet Pharmacy. Best Prices.
  • Buy Cheapest internet pharmacy cod Now Cheap Online Pharmacy. Free Viagra Pills!
  • Buy Cheap buy now online viagra Online Special Prices For buy now online viagra! Low Prices.
  • Buy Cheapest cialis online consultation Online Cheap Online Pharmacy. Best Drugstore.
  • Buy Cheapest prescription pain reliever Now Cheap Pharmacy Online. Free Viagra Pills!
  • Buy Cheap buy medication online Online 100% Satisfaction Guaranteed. Low Prices.
  • Buy Cheap buy bactrim Online Cheap Pharmacy Online. Best Drugstore.
  • Buy Cheapest guaranteed cheapest viagra Online Top Online Pharmacy. Pharmacy Store.
  • Buy Cheapest withdrawal from effexor Online Cheap Pharmacy Online. Best Drugstore.
  • Buying Cheap real phentermine. Offshore Pharmacy, Good Prices. Best Internet.
  • Buy Cheap online mexican pharmacy Online Best Online. Pharmacy At The Best Price!
  • Buy Cheapest tadalafil jelly Now Low Prices. 100% Satisfaction Guaranteed.
  • Buy Cheap weight loss nutrition program Now Best Internet. 100% Satisfaction Guaranteed.
  • Buy Cheap genaric cialis Now Special Prices For genaric cialis! Free Viagra Pills!
  • Buy Cheapest rating on weight loss programs Online Low Prices. Cheap Pharmacy Online.
  • Buy Cheap getting viagra in the philippines Online Best Online. 24/Internet)(safe Pharmacy.
  • Buy Cheap anti anxiety depression drug side effects Online Discount Pharmacy Online. Low Prices.
  • Buy Cheap diflucan pill Now Best Drugstore. 100% Satisfaction Guaranteed.
  • phentermine consultation Online Without Prescription Best Prices. WorldWide Shipping.
  • Buy Cheap discount meds Online Buy Medications Online. WorldWide Shipping.
  • Buy Cheap buy pain medicine online Now Best Internet. Order Cheap Meds Without Rx.
  • Buy Cheapest information ultram Now Special Prices For information ultram! Best Online.
  • Buy Cheap where to order fioricet with codeine Now No Prescription Needed. Guaranteed Shipping.
  • Buy Cheap rapid weight loss pills for sale Online Free Viagra Pills! 24/Online Pharmacy.
  • Buy Cheap next day tramadol Online Low Prices. Order Cheap Meds Without Rx.
  • Buy Cheap discount brand-name cialis Now Best Internet. Safe And Secure Payment System.
  • Buy Cheap drugs online Online Best Prices. Discount Pharmacy Online.
  • Buy Cheapest cures for impotence Online WorldWide Shipping. Free Viagra Pills!
  • Buy Cheap vitamin supplement ratings Online Cheap Online Pharmacy. Online Medical Shop.
  • Buy Cheapest xanax withdrawl symptoms Online Best Online. Top Online Pharmacy.
  • Buy Cheapest buy cheap amoxil without prescription Online Pharmacy Store. Free Viagra Pills!
  • Buy Cheapest lowest price levitra Now Low Prices. Discount Pharmacy Online.
  • Buy buy plavix online Online Without Prescription. Best Online. Best Prices.
  • Buy Cheap pain killer no prescription mexico Online Buy Medications Online. Best Online.
  • Buy Cheapest valium low cost Now Special Prices For valium low cost! Low Prices.
  • Buy Cheapest online pharmacy ativan Now Cheap Prescription Drugs. Low Prices.
  • Buy Cheapest vitamins for healthy skin Online Best Online. Discount Online Pharmacy.
  • Buy Cheap buy diazepam online Now Free Viagra Pills! No Prescription Needed.
  • Buy prices tramadol Without Prescription Doctor. Low Prices. Best Drugstore.
  • Buy Cheapest fat burning progarm Now No Prescription Needed. Free Viagra Pills!
  • Buy Cheapest tablet zolpidem Online Top Online Pharmacy. WorldWide Shipping.
  • Buy Cheapest buy alprazolam no prescription Online Buy Medications Online. Best Drugstore.
  • Buy Cheapest fluoxetine hcl Online Online Prices For fluoxetine hcl! Low Prices.
  • Buy Cheapest prescription sleep aid medications Online Online Medical Shop. Free Viagra Pills!
  • Buy Cheap cheap tramadol no prescription Now Low Prices. FDA Approved Rx: Online Pharmacy.
  • Buy Cheapest fucidin cream Online Cheap Pharmacy Online. Low Prices.
  • Buy Cheapest tramadol 100mg Now Best Drugstore. No Prescription Needed.
  • Buy Cheap overseas drug stores Online Order Cheap Meds Without Rx. Low Prices.
  • Buy Cheapest generic for nexium Online Low Prices. Discount Pharmacy Online.
  • Buy Cheapest cheap cialis find Online Best Online. Cheap Online Pharmacy.
  • Buy Cheapest phentermine risk Now Cheap Online Pharmacy. WorldWide Shipping.
  • Buy Cheap new drug cialis Now Best Drugstore. Pharmacy At The Best Price!
  • Buy Cheapest cheap viagra canada Online Low Prices. Online Prices For cheap viagra canada!
  • Buy Cheap xanax on line with out prescription Online Free Viagra Pills! Buy Medications Online.
  • tips for weight loss Online Without Prescription Best Prices. Best Drugstore.
  • Buy Cheap atorvastatin lipitor Now Buy Medications Online. Cheap Pharmacy Online.
  • Buy Cheap buy generic drugs Now Cheap Pharmacy Online. Buy Medications Online.
  • Buy Cheapest buy cheap clonazepam without a prescription Online Best Prices. Cheap Prescription Drugs.
  • Buy Cheap canadian arthritis medication Online Best Prices. 100% Satisfaction Guaranteed.
  • Buy Cheapest rating male erectile dysfunction products Online Best Online. Online Prices For rating male erectile dysfunction products!
  • Buy Cheap prescription medicine for acne Now Best Prices. 24/Internet)(safe Pharmacy.
  • Buy Cheapest ultram best price Now Best Online. Pharmacy At The Best Price!
  • Buy Cheap dietary supplement buy Online Discount Online Pharmacy. Pharmacy Store.
  • Buy Cheapest clomid taking Now Low Prices. Cheap Prescription Drugs.
  • Buy Cheapest pharmacies buy xanax without prescription Online Get FDA Approved Prescription Medicines.
  • Buy Cheapest canada meds Online Buy Medications Online. Best Internet.
  • Buy Cheapest benicar dosage Now Pharmacy Store. Online Medical Shop.
  • Buy Cheapest online prescription viagra without Now Best Online. Top Online Pharmacy Supplier.